MoversSomeguy↓416Afi↓374Grethos↓352Abhi | AP Collective @ Token 2049 🇸🇬↓281Majdi↓266TradeSk0rp.eth↑48.8%Brandon scott↑1.0%vitalik.eth↑1.7%Ethos↑1.0%VouchesSyrup69 WHUF → OSFDpuck (bob)30 WHUF → KingPickle 🪑Dpuck (bob)25 WHUF → osamafaheemm🤝Samorityanin🧢20 WHUF → 一川drive 🔴ReviewsCoinbase Ventures 🛡️positive · 95 upvotes一川drive 🔴positive · 40 upvotesaiobkhan ✨positive · 30 upvotesMark Karpelèspositive · 21 upvotes
Profile· Neutral@HumnPassportOn Ethos
Human Passport

Human Passport

5 reviews, 20% of them positive.20% positive · 5 reviews· Influence factor 29, above 6% of accounts
“Awful!”I used to recommend Human Passport for sybil protection, but oh boy do I regret it now. I used to have over 2x the required "Human Score" from the NFT and ETH activity badges alone - because I have a lot of NFTs and I've been active onchain for the past 4 and a half year on my public wallet. I do not sybil, I do not use automated tools. My activity has been pretty consistent. For clarity: 2922 tx on mainnet ETH / over 1630 days (4 years, 170 days) = avg. 1.79tx per day + 744tx on Base and some exploratory activity on other L2s, but mostly sticking to mainnet ETH. All of that is obviously organic activity. A project I was looking into required having a passable Humanity score, so I went to check my Passport since some badges require a refresh every ~90 days - suddenly all my onchain activity was nuked to the bare minimum. Shouldn't consistent activity and collecting more NFTs actually make my score higher or at least maintain it? (my score was already maxxed out!) Well, the people from Passport weren't really helpful, didn't want to investigate what happened and couldn't tell me why. They couldn't tell me anything because they "do not want people to know the mechanics and game the system". I obviously don't care about their mechanics, but I want some clarity on why my onchain score went from MAX to ZERO. Considering my onchain activity and NFT collection grew - the score that was already maxxed out shouldn't get lower. Especially not that low: https://x.com/badboykrys/status/1955526501111103667 https://x.com/badboykrys/status/1955530083386658913 My collection of 1700+ NFTs includes: plenty verified collections, 100+ ENS domains, collections deployed on manifold / makersplace / niftygateway / foundation / knownorigin / scatter, etc My Passport NFT score? It used to be maxxed out - now it ticks the "owns 1 NFT" box... LOL I was part of OS closed beta and Blur closed beta and did quite some product testing in web3 (remember SoHo portfolio tracker? I contributed to that as well and I still dearly miss that wonderful app...). My onchain reputation being nuked to 0 is seriously awful. Getting Passport to give me an answer why that happened or getting them to investigate - impossible. Now the only option to get to a passable humanity score - "Verify your identity with government ID". So now I have to KYC my public wallet to participate in some projects using Passport for anti-sybil? Eww! Recommending them to projects surely did misfire LMAO I obviously am not going to upload my ID in relation to my public wallet - but I also don't want to set up a new wallet and build up a transaction history and reputation on it - when I already have a public wallet with 4 YEARS 170 DAYS OF ORGANIC ACTIVITY! But those are my only options since I am basically blacklisted as a sybil and prevented from project participation / getting airdrops... Today I reached out to Passport again since another project I was interested in is using them - but got the same answer, can't investigate, can't tell me why my score got lower - but they mentioned they are using TRUSTA and being flagged there might impact my Passport score. I guess the person of contact told me why I'm flagged without really telling me why I'm flagged - I guess that's internal policy lol Apparently Trusta uses AI to auto flag wallets and weigh their reputation / flag sybils. And apparently their system, which is used by many projects, is flawed and falsely flagging organic users as sybils/bots. So that means any project that uses Trusta will flag me. And projects that don't use Trusta might use Passport -which also uses Trusta... That means this Trusta flag impacting the Passport score leads to being blacklisted across a lot of reputation score systems and getting flagged as inorganic/sybil/bot across pretty much every upcoming airdrop - because projects will use one of those services to filter out sybils. If they don't use Trusta, they will use Passport - which also uses Trusta. GG!Username McUserface ( ͠° ͟ʖ ͡°) · 1460· 1y ago · negative4
5 of 5 · most upvoted first